RN Nursing · Ethics and Decision Making · Practice question
Which statement is correct regarding the distinction between legal and ethical obligations in decision making?
-
Ethical controls are much clearer and individualized.
-
Legal controls are much less clear and individualized.
-
✓
Legal controls are clearer and philosophically impartial.
-
Ethical controls are clearer and philosophically impartial.
Answer & explanation
Correct: Legal controls are clearer and philosophically impartial.
Legal controls are characterized by being clearer and more philosophically impartial than ethical standards. Laws are codified, publicly accessible, and applied uniformly across individuals regardless of personal values or cultural background; a judge or regulatory body applies legal standards using established precedent and defined criteria. This clarity and impartiality make legal obligations more predictable. Ethical obligations, by contrast, arise from moral principles, values, and professional codes that can vary among individuals, cultures, and professional organizations. Because ethics are rooted in personal and professional values, they are often less clear-cut and more individualized, meaning two professionals could face the same situation and reach different but equally defensible ethical conclusions. The statement that ethical controls are clearer and philosophically impartial is incorrect because ethics involve subjective value judgments. Saying legal controls are less clear and individualized is also incorrect because laws are specifically designed to be standardized and uniform. The statement that ethical controls are much clearer and individualized is self-contradictory because clarity and individualization are opposing qualities in this context. Therefore, the correct characterization is that legal controls are clearer and philosophically impartial, distinguishing them from the more nuanced and value-laden nature of ethical decision making.
Practise Ethics and Decision Making questions
Work through full question sets with instant rationales, timed exams, and progress tracking.
Start practising freeRelated practice questions
- The Code of Ethics for Nurses compels nurses to recognize the dignity, worth, and unique attributes of each person they care for, and to practice compassion and respect for all persons.
- A nurse-manager is discussing a proposed change in practice the interdisciplinary team. What question by the manager best reflects a utilitarian perspective?
- A client refuses treatment for a new cancer diagnosis. How should the nurse best respond?
- The A nurse is applying the ethical principle of justice when providing care for clients. What action best exemplifies this principle? Ensuring that time and resources are distributed equitably to clients